In the early stages of the Cleveland Browns' rookie minicamp, fifth-round draft pick Shedeur Sanders has emerged as a standout performer, drawing attention for his impressive throws and leadership qualities. Despite being selected later in the draft than third-round pick Dillon Gabriel, Sanders has reportedly outperformed his fellow rookie quarterback, according to multiple analysts and observers .
During the minicamp sessions, Sanders showcased his arm strength and accuracy, with one notable 81.5-yard pass that potentially surpasses Baker Mayfield's previous record. Analysts like Zac Jackson of The Athletic have remarked on Sanders' superior throwing ability, stating, "In just throwing the ball, it's not close: Shedeur Sanders." Former NFL running back LeSean McCoy echoed this sentiment, noting that Sanders appeared to be the best player at the camp .
CLEVELAND, OH — In what many are calling a surprising yet decisive early development, rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders is making waves at Cleveland Browns minicamp — and by all accounts, he's pulling away from the competition.
According to team insiders and beat reporters attending the closed practices, Sanders has been outshining fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel with ease. While both were mid-round picks — Gabriel in the 3rd round and Sanders in the 5th — sources close to the Browns’ staff are saying the gap in performance “isn’t even close.”
Throwing Dimes & Commanding the Huddle
Sanders has reportedly displayed elite arm talent, poise under pressure, and a quick grasp of the playbook. His mechanics have been described as “NFL-ready,” and his ball placement in red zone and tight-window situations is catching the attention of coaches and veterans alike.
One source familiar with the Browns’ quarterback room said, “Every time Shedeur drops back, the ball comes out with confidence and purpose. He’s putting it where only the receiver can get it. Gabriel has talent, but right now, Shedeur looks like the better pro.”
In one standout moment at practice, Sanders reportedly uncorked a deep ball over 80 yards in the air, drawing audible reactions from the sidelines. Coaches immediately replayed the sequence on tablets, nodding in approval.
Work Ethic & Leadership Are Setting the Tone
Perhaps more impressive than his arm strength is Sanders' maturity and presence. He’s been staying late after practice, working with receivers, reviewing plays, and setting an example. Multiple teammates have commented that he “carries himself like a starter,” even though he’s listed as QB4 on the depth chart for now.
One veteran said, “He’s not acting like a guy who’s just happy to be here. He’s acting like he’s coming for a job. You respect that.”
Shedeur Sanders is already turning heads at Browns mini camp.
— BallerPost (@BallerPost) May 13, 2025
Wearing #12, he's stepping into Cleveland with poise, command, and a chip on his shoulder.
???? According to team sources, he's already separating himself from the other rookies.
???? Let the QB battle begin.#DawgPound pic.twitter.com/nA6WeOLUXh
Gabriel Playing Catch-Up
While Gabriel hasn’t necessarily looked bad, his timing has been off and his throws have lacked the same velocity and precision. In 7-on-7 drills, Gabriel reportedly struggled to get through progressions fast enough, leading to batted balls and a couple of near-picks.
Sources say the coaching staff is pleased with Gabriel’s character and football IQ but admit that he’s looked “a step behind” compared to Sanders in nearly every category — reads, timing, and on-field command.
A team evaluator noted, “It’s early, and no one’s writing anyone off. But if this were a live competition for reps in Week 1, Shedeur’s winning.”
Stefanski Playing It Cool — But Eyes Are Watching
Head Coach Kevin Stefanski has remained diplomatic when asked about the quarterback evaluations, repeating that it’s a “learning environment” and that “everyone will get their shot.” But internally, it's clear that Sanders has seized early momentum.
There’s even chatter within the organization that the Browns may consider reshuffling their quarterback development plans if Sanders continues this pace through OTAs.
Why This Matters
Let’s be clear — this isn’t just about camp reps. The Browns, with Deshaun Watson locked in as their starter, aren’t looking for a QB1. But they are looking for a long-term backup and developmental prospect to groom behind Watson. With Sanders’ high football pedigree (being the son of Deion Sanders), work ethic, and early on-field performance, he’s making a very real case to be that guy — and perhaps more.
Final Take
Shedeur Sanders came into this rookie minicamp with doubters. Many scouts labeled him a “system QB” from Colorado. But in just a few practices, he’s flipping that narrative.
And if you ask anyone in that facility right now?
It’s not even close.
—
